Why do we tell ourselves negative stories? Our brains are wired to make assumptions, and it’s a natural part of how we navigate uncertainty. However, when it comes to the workplace, these assumptions can do more harm than good. As leaders, understanding the science behind these mental shortcuts and learning to reframe our thinking can transform how we interact with our teams. In this week’s episode of Reflect Forward, we dive into the stories we tell ourselves and how to stop the negative narrative.

Why We Tell Ourselves Stories

Human beings are wired to seek coherence. When information is incomplete or ambiguous, our brains fill in the gaps with stories to make sense of what we see. While this can be helpful in some situations, it often leads to misunderstandings in complex environments like the workplace.

Cognitive biases are at the core of this process—mental shortcuts that help us make quick decisions but can also distort our perceptions. Three common biases that influence workplace storytelling are confirmation bias, fundamental attribution error, and negative bias:

• Confirmation bias: We tend to interpret information in ways that confirm our pre-existing beliefs. If you believe a team member is disengaged, you’re more likely to notice signs that reinforce that story and ignore evidence that contradicts it.
• Fundamental attribution error: We often attribute others’ actions to their personality or character rather than considering external factors. For example, if someone misses a deadline, we might assume they’re lazy or unorganized rather than thinking about their potential challenges.
• Negative bias: The human brain focuses on and remembers negative experiences or information. In the workplace, this means we’re more prone to noticing problems or conflicts, and we may overlook positive actions or intentions. For example, you might focus on one piece of critical feedback in an otherwise positive review, amplifying a negative story in your mind.

These mental shortcuts served us well in our evolutionary past but can create toxic workplace dynamics today. As leaders, we are responsible for recognizing when we’re falling into these patterns and actively seeking to challenge them.

The Danger of Inaccurate Stories

Inaccurate stories lead to misunderstandings, mistrust, and disengagement within teams. The stories we tell ourselves—whether it’s about an employee’s performance or a peer’s behavior—often result in decisions that are out of alignment with reality. This disconnect can cause tension, erode relationships, and foster a culture of negativity.

How to Reframe the Story

To break free from inaccurate stories, leaders should pause and reflect before reacting. Start by practicing mindfulness to become aware of the assumptions you’re making. Challenge these assumptions by asking, “What evidence do I have?” and “What else could be true?” Finally, try to see the situation from the other person’s perspective, considering their challenges and pressures. Reframing allows you to approach situations with clarity and empathy, leading to better communication and more constructive outcomes.

Seek to Understand Before Judging

As leaders, it’s crucial to seek understanding before jumping to conclusions. Instead of making assumptions, cultivate curiosity by asking open-ended questions like, “Can you help me understand what happened?” and actively listening with the intent to understand, not just to respond. Doing so creates space for genuine dialogue and empathy, fostering a culture of trust and reducing misunderstandings. Remember, when in doubt, assume good intentions—this simple shift can transform team dynamics and create a more positive work environment.

Stop Telling Yourself Stories

Reframing assumptions and seeking understanding is a key component of leadership. Reducing inaccurate stories and creating space for curiosity and empathy fosters a workplace where people feel valued and understood. As a leader, committing to the following can have a significant impact on your team’s success:

• Pause, Reflect, Reframe: Notice when you’re making assumptions and practice challenging your initial thoughts.
• Embrace Curiosity: Ask questions and seek to understand before forming conclusions.
• Assume Good Intentions: Approach every interaction with the belief that others mean well, creating a culture of trust and openness.
• Hold Yourself Accountable: Stop the negative narrative, own your triggers and stories and be a role model.

By embracing these practices, you’ll not only improve your own leadership capabilities but also create a more positive, collaborative, and high-performing workplace for your team.

You can order my book, The Ownership Mindset, on Amazon or Barnes and Noble

Follow me on Instagram or LinkedIn.
Subscribe to my podcast Reflect Forward on iTunes

Or check out my new YouTube Channel, where you can watch full-length episodes of Advice From a CEO!

And if you are looking for a keynote speaker or a podcast guest, click here to book a meeting with me to discuss what you are looking for!